
Leonard Chesterfield Miller had just pulled into a gas station while working as a delivery driver when a Georgia cop pulled the Black man out of his car, handcuffed him, and groped him without explaining the reason why.
“I just got sexually assaulted in front of everyone,” Miller said after the officer handcuffed him in December 2022.
“You’re extremely lucky you did not get shot right there,” Grovetown Police Officer Patrick Brown Sr. told him, according to bodycam footage police initially denied existed.
Last month, Miller filed a federal lawsuit against Brown and Sgt. Anthony Plyler, alleging excessive force, unlawful searches, and fabricated claims of physical resistance to support an obstruction charge.
The lawsuit also accuses Plyler of helping Brown restrain Miller and failing to intervene as Miller cried out in pain.
According to the lawsuit, Brown eventually told Miller that officers suspected him of involvement in a hit-and-run because his 2010 white Ford Fusion matched the description of another white sedan, reportedly no newer than a 2014 model.
Even after determining that Miller’s car was not the vehicle they were looking for, Brown allegedly insisted on taking him to jail because he disliked Miller’s attitude.
“He’s got to go to jail,” Brown said.
“But he’s not our hit-and-run, so…” Plyler responded.
“He’s got to go to jail, acting like that,” Brown insisted. “Having to tussle with him and all that stuff.”
Officers jailed Miller overnight on a misdemeanor charge of obstruction, which remained pending for more than three years before prosecutors dismissed the charge in January 2026. Cops also cited him for a defective headlight.
“Brown’s physical abuse, unwanted genital contact, and the resulting arrest aggravated that preexisting condition and precipitated a severe deterioration in Mr. Miller’s psychiatric health.”
Brown approached Miller at around 8:01 p.m. on Dec. 29, 2022, at a Walmart Neighborhood Market gas station, where he was buying fuel before returning to work for Grubhub.
Brown received a hit-and-run report describing an older white sedan with possible front-end damage, a damaged or nonfunctioning driver’s-side headlight, and dark-tinted windows.
The cops had neither a license plate nor a description identifying the driver, according to the claim.
Not knowing anything about the hit-and-run, Miller was sitting in the driver’s seat with his feet outside the car, looking at his phone when Brown began shouting commands without first identifying himself or explaining the investigation, the claim states.
Bodycam video shows Brown initially ordering Miller to remain inside the car, then ordering him out of the car. Miller says he stayed seated when instructed and submitted when Brown grabbed his wrist and compelled him to exit.
“Now you’re making me nervous,” Miller said. “What did I do?”
Brown accused Miller of trying to pull a gun on him, but the video shows he was only holding a phone in one hand. There was also a gun on the floor of the car, which Miller legally possessed.
“You have a gun right there,” the cop told him after pulling him out of the car.
“I have a gun license too,” Miller responded.
Brown continued escalating the confrontation without ever telling Miller he was detaining him.
“During the initial frisk, Defendant Brown subjected Mr. Miller to unwanted and sexually abusive contact with his genitals, prompting immediate protests of sexual assault,” the claim states before describing the second alleged sexual assault.
“During that search, Brown again subjected Mr. Miller to unwanted sexual contact, squeezing his testicles and pinching his penis while Mr. Miller remained handcuffed and under the physical control of both officers.”
“You just touched my nuts and everything,” Miller said after the second time, according to bodycam footage. “It’s on cameras right there, dude.”
“Ouch!” Miller yelled in pain. “You just squeezed my d*ck!”
“You have anything on you other than the gun you tried to pull?” Brown asked.
“I did not try to pull no gun,” Miller responded.
In an affidavit seeking an obstruction warrant, Brown claimed Miller “did refuse to obey verbal commands to exit the vehicle during a traffic stop and became physically combative,” according to the lawsuit, which disputes that account.
Miller alleges that Brown failed to acknowledge his own conflicting instructions and mischaracterized Miller’s questions, objections, and reactions to painful restraints as unlawful resistance.
“It’s not illegal to have a gun, but it is illegal to unlawfully resist a law enforcement officer,” Brown told Miller during the arrest.
Officers inspected Miller’s car, compared its damage with evidence from the collision, and determined it was not involved in the hit-and-run, according to the lawsuit.
Brown nevertheless arrested him for obstruction, forcing Miller to spend the night in jail before his father posted a $1,330 cash bond the following day.
Grovetown police did not release Plyler’s bodycam footage to Miller until February 2, after prosecutors dismissed his charge in January. Miller later posted the video to YouTube, but it did not capture his initial encounter with Brown.
On February 16, Grovetown Police Chief Jamey Kitchens issued a press release on the department’s Facebook page suggesting that Brown was not wearing a body camera, which would explain why the department only released Plyler’s footage.
Four days later, however, the YouTube police accountability channel We the People U published the footage in a 17-minute video titled “Fire Him, We Got the Body Cam Now,” along with its own analysis.
Miller alleges the encounter aggravated his preexisting PTSD and led to a severe decline in his mental health. A judge later found him incompetent to stand trial on the obstruction charge and ordered him to undergo inpatient treatment to restore his competency, according to the lawsuit.
“The forcible restraint, humiliating searches, and continued detention caused him physical suffering, fear, humiliation, and emotional distress,” the lawsuit states.
It remains unclear whether the department or the officers have responded to Miller’s federal lawsuit.