‘Why Are People Laughing?’: Trump Honors Teen Lifeguard During Oval Office Meeting, Then Leans In to Whisper Something Cruel to a 10-Year-Old

    Donald Trump extended a White House invite to celebrate the 16-year-old lifeguard who saved a drowning child.

    Instead, the president turned the teen’s big hero day into a story that has almost nothing to do with the rescue.

    Then, Trump opened his mouth. 

    Trump admits he “probably” wouldn’t have saved 10-year-old Nathaniel Rai, right, during an Oval Office ceremony on Aug. 17. (Photos: Getty Images)

    On July 25, 10-year-old Nathaniel Rai was swept away at Seabright State Beach in Santa Cruz, California, roughly 60 miles south of San Francisco.

    Waves were running as high as 10 feet. Ryder Williams, a first-year California State Parks lifeguard, radioed it in, threw down his sunglasses, and ran.

    ‘Shameful’: Trump’s Latest Golf Victory Faces Fresh Cheating Claims as Ex-Caddie Exposes Strange ‘Deal’ Behind His 40 Wins

    On Monday, Aug. 17, Trump hosted both boys, along with both of their families, as well as the Santa Cruz officials who trained Williams.

    He reached the boy, wrapped an arm around his chest, and refused to let go. At one point, the two disappeared from the frame entirely before resurfacing.

    A second lifeguard, Aaron Bohnen, finally helped drag them ashore. Bystander Scott Vander Dussen filmed the moment in a viral video that caught Trump’s attention.

    His son, Eric Trump, reposted the clip, calling it the best of America and demanding the teen get the country’s highest civilian honor. Trump agreed and announced on Truth Social on July 28 that he would bring the “heroic young man” to the White House.

    That promise is what put everyone in the Oval Office on Monday.

    Trump praised Williams generously at first. He called the rescue incredible. He said he had rewound the video to make sure he was seeing it right.

    “He’s a real hero,” Trump said. But then he pivoted to himself.

    He leaned in toward Rai, lowered his voice to whisper something rather cruel to say to anyone after a life-threatening event.

    The POTUS said, “I wouldn’t probably” have done the same and then added, “You’re lucky I wasn’t on the service that day.”

    Adding insult to injury, Trump said, “He’s a real lucky guy too. God was watching you, right?”

    He was smiling. Several people in the room laughed. Nathaniel, who nearly drowned three weeks earlier, sat right there. Needless to say, the internet was not laughing.

    The clip spread within hours across various social platforms… and the reaction was loud.

    “In his world, choosing to let a child die in the surf is hilarious,” one X user wrote. Another kept it short: “Yes, we know he’s the biggest coward on the planet.” A third asked the question that racked up the most agreement: “Why are people laughing? Sycophants…. All of them.”

    One reply zeroed in on the staff standing behind him, wondering aloud whether they admit at home that they laughed while an old man turned a brave kid’s moment into a bit about himself.

    Elsewhere, others saw things differently. ”Trump isn’t a lifeguard,” one wrote, arguing that a rescue attempt by the president would have produced two victims instead of one.

    The teenager, for his part, never actually made it about himself.

    Asked what was running through his mind, Williams said lifeguards fall back on their training and that he was focused on getting the boy out of the water as fast as possible. Asked what he wanted his generation to take from it, he said people should look out for one another.

    The now-viral Oval Office moment isn’t the only awkward beat from Monday’s meeting, though.

    During the same visit, Trump fumbled the teen hero’s name and made a strange remark about his mother’s genetics.

    “Shannon Williams, that’s the mom. You did a good job; it’s good genetics when you look at him; you can see. Really good job,” he told her.

    Whatever the case, the ceremony stopped being about Ryder Williams. And that pattern is familiar by now.

    The now-viral Oval Office moment isn’t the only awkward beat from Monday’s meeting, where Trump made it about him.

    By the time the meeting ended, the lifeguard wasn’t the only person navigating rough waters. Trump had joked about his own rescue skills, stumbled through the teen’s big moment.

    He turned on a reporter for asking a question he didn’t like.

    Trump snapped when a CNN reporter tried to ask about North Korea, calling the question disrespectful in front of the children. He told her to “Be quiet,” before labeling her “fake news.”

    Back to top