Outrage Grows as Rabbis Who Admitted to Recklessly Starting Deadly Nursing Home Fire Avoid Jail Time: ‘Horrendous Act’

Two Rabbis Get Probation For New York Nursing Home Fire
Nathaniel Sommer and his son, Aaron, were given several years of probation for the deadly fire that killed two people in 2021. (CBS New York/YouTube)

Two rabbis who admitted to causing a fire at a New York nursing home were given no time behind bars — leaving the community and first responders outraged.

Nathaniel Sommer and his son, Aaron, were charged in connection to the deadly fire at Evergreen Court Home for Adults in March 2021, WABC reported. The rabbis used a propane blowtorch and coal in a ritual to prepare the kitchen and ovens before Passover. Sommer has carried out the cleansing of the area at the home for 15 years.

Two people died due to the fire, including Jared Lloyd, a Spring Valley volunteer firefighter, and a 79-year-old resident identified as Oliver Hueston. Lloyd was on the scene, saving residents from the blaze before he died. 

Sommer,71, pleaded guilty to two counts of manslaughter and Aaron, 29, to reckless endangerment after reaching a deal earlier this year. And on Wednesday, Sept. 21, according to reports, a judge gave the duo several years of probation and ordered them to pay $600 in court-related fees. 

Related: White Homeowner Claims Self-Defense In Shooting of Black Teen Ralph Yarl Who Rang the Wrong Doorbell; Attorney Maintains There’s ‘No Evidence’ That Race Played a Role

Rockland County court judge Kevin Russo argued that the rabbis have never “been arrested, much less convicted,” CBS News reported. At the sentencing, Sommers acknowledged how his actions had impacted the families involved.

“I tried my whole life to help people, and I did the exact opposite here. I have hurt so many people, and I feel terrible for them,” Sommer said, per the outlets. 

According to the Rockland/Westchester Journal News, dozens gathered to protest outside the courthouse. Inside, however, Lloyd’s mother called for justice and emotionally reiterated how Lloyd’s death would affect not only her for life but his children as well. 

Firefighter Jared Lloyd was killed while saving residents during a fire at a New York assisted living facility in March 2021. (CBS New York/YouTube screenshot)

“We know this will not bring Jared back, but out of respect for my son Jared and his fellow firefighting brothers in Rockland County, no jail time is not an option,” Sabrail Davenport said in court, the outlet reported. “I am praying that you all consider the pain that this horrendous act has caused me and my family. I’m praying also that you search your conscience because you will have to live with your decision for the rest of your life.”

Rockland County Executive Ed Day also chimed in, stating that he does not concur with the sentencing the rabbis received, citing their “reckless and felonious behavior.”

“As I have stated countless times, the Lloyd and Hueston families do not feel this is justice for their loved ones who perished in that fire. I extend my heartfelt condolences to the families now serving a life sentence as they mourn the loved ones serving a death sentence,” Day said, according to WABC.

Read the full story on Atlanta Black Star.

Subscribe To The ABS Newsletter — Get our stories in your inbox.

Independent journalism still matters.

We hope this story was worth your time. For over 14 years, Atlanta Black Star has stayed Black-owned and independently run. We didn't get here by waiting on ad budgets that were never built to prioritize us. Our readers did that.

Corporate support for Black media has always been thin. Outlets like ours get roughly 1% of the $170 billion spent on U.S. advertising each year, and that margin is shrinking further as advertisers walk back the DEI-linked commitments they made in 2020. That's the backdrop. It's not why we're asking.

The wider picture isn't any steadier. Newspaper ad revenue has fallen more than 80% since 2005, and local newsrooms are closing at a rate of roughly two a week nationwide. When outlets go under, it's rarely the ones built to center a Black perspective from the ground up that get to stick around.

We know a request for support isn't why you came here. But without readers choosing to fund this work directly, the depth of reporting we can do at home and abroad shrinks along with everyone else's. If you're not in a position to give, that doesn't change how much we value you as a reader.

If you are able to, a recurring contribution does more for us than a single one-time gift, because it lets us plan the next investigation instead of just the next invoice. It takes about 30 seconds, no long form, no account. Thank you for continuing to support independent journalism and freedom of the press.

Latest from Atlanta Black Star

Back to top