Trending Topics

Scholar Says Standardized Tests Don’t Accurately Grade Black Students

In recent years, harrowing statistics regarding the aptitude of black students in America have been run through the media with alarming frequency. In 2010, the New York Times reported that only 12 percent of black fourth-grade boys were proficient in reading, compared to 38 percent of white boys. Those figures came from a study produced by The Council of the Great City Schools, a group that advocates for higher standards in the public schools of major cities nationwide.

When such figures are put forth, the performance of black students is often attributed to social conditions and biased testing, but few questions are asked about why black students specifically underperform across the board, and even fewer solutions are put in place.

Dr. Ivory A. Toldson questions not only the tests and socio-economic positions that face many of America’s black students, but also the criteria by which black students are judged. Toldson gives the example of a typical African-American fourth grader, confronted by a standardized test, which does not affect his regular schooling. A tenured professor at Howard University, Toldson offers his opinion of the black education experience in an editorial on The Root.

“To test his level of reading comprehension, he is given a two-page passage about bees. Although he can read every word, the passage is extremely boring to him. Because the test is timed, he has to use a particular style of reading that feels contrived,” Toldson writes via The Root. “At the end, he has to answer a series of questions, which have many plausible answers. In general, attributes like imagination and creativity work against him because the test requires him to be literal and deductive.”

Using his own background as a likely sufferer of ADD who struggled through standard schooling, along with the scenarios seen across the country in which black students with straight A’s are being held back due to reading proficiency tests, Toldson makes a case that black students are being measured by invalid standards.

While he recognizes the poor scores as an issue within the black community, he does not link them to an absolute literary crisis.

“We cannot deny the literacy problems in the black community; however, I’m convinced that the problem lies less with children and more with the lack of understanding among adults of multiple literacies,” he writes.

Toldson charges his readers to consider more than just the results of standardized tests. Certainly the scores should not be completely disregarded, but how effective are they in measuring the progress of black students and their aptitude for learning. Should black students be forced to fit the mold put forth by a system that seemingly reinforces black inferiority, he asks, or should they be encouraged to follow their own paths for growth?

What people are saying

2 thoughts on “Scholar Says Standardized Tests Don’t Accurately Grade Black Students

  1. Mocho Shorter says:

    so wouldn't the passage about bees be boring for white students and any other student as well? I have always scored very high on aptitude test, and I attribute that to my fathers involvement with my education.At an early age he bought me an entire volume of encyclopedia with a trivia gadget that you spin and answer questions. Sent me to private school that he really coulnt afford but he knew the value of good education.Parents have to be involved but with a lot of parents struggling, working long hours, etc many intelligent black kids fall to the wayside.

  2. Aptitude tests have always bothered because there is so much involved that has nothing to do with a student's aptitude to excel in a certain field. And by that, I mean the big business of test preparation. I'd be willing to bet that the difference aptitude test results is better explained by socioeconomic status than race, but these two things are often used interchangeably. I'm not saying you shouldn't be able to take aptitude test prep courses but it's something we have to consider when having this type of discussion.

Leave a Reply

Back to top