Trump’s Judge Pick Visibly Unravels Over Third-Term Question, But Dem Corners Him and Refuses to Let Him Off the Hook 

The Texas Supreme Court Justice The Texas Supreme Court justice

President Donald Trump‘s federal court pick is making waves online for a viral moment that highlights the stark reality of his administration.

James Sullivan had a moment during his confirmation hearing when a simple question about the Constitution appeared to leave him searching for an answer he should have known.

The Texas Supreme Court justice struggled to recall the 22nd Amendment, muttering, “Oh boy, oh boy.” Even after Sen. Chris Coons explained its meaning, Sullivan declined to say whether the Constitution barred Trump from serving a third term.

The exchange, circulating widely on social media, has raised questions about Sullivan’s grasp of the Constitution as he seeks a lifetime appointment to the federal bench, particularly after he appeared unable to answer a straightforward question about presidential term limits before pivoting to concerns about whether the subject was politically controversial.

Coons, a Delaware Democrat serving on the Senate Judiciary Committee, began by asking Sullivan to explain the 22nd Amendment, which limits presidents to two terms.

“Since we’re just talking about the importance of taking the oath to uphold the Constitution — Mr. Sullivan, can you just tell me what the Twenty-Second Amendment provides?” Coons asked.

Sullivan appeared to struggle to recall the amendment, even acknowledging that he sometimes had trouble remembering what he knew.

“Senator, if I’m remembering correctly — and I carry it over my heart because sometimes it isn’t in my brain — but if I’m remembering it correctly, it is —” Sullivan said before pausing and whispering, “Oh boy, oh boy,” as he strained to respond.

He then declined to give a definitive answer, saying he wasn’t sure he could respond because some might see the issue as politically contentious.

“And so, respectfully, I’m not so sure that I can. I mean, I can certainly tell you how I would think about approaching a problem like that. But this seems like both — it certainly seems like it’s the sort of thing that is a subject of ongoing political debate. And Canon 5C of the canons that would apply to us as nominees,” he said, according to Mediaite.

Coons wasn’t buying that explanation. He argued that the amendment’s language was clear and that a judicial nominee shouldn’t treat it as a disputed political question.

“That’s a very disappointing answer. It strikes me as just bracingly clear on the face of it. A textualist, anyone who has read the Constitution and is sitting before me for confirmation for a lifetime appointment, I don’t think it is the subject of political debate.”

Coons acknowledged that judicial nominees may have reason to avoid weighing in on unsettled legal questions but said the constitutional restriction on presidential terms was not one of them.

“I respect your reading of Canon 5, and if I were asking you a question that was the subject of vigorous political debate and unsettled as a matter of constitutional law or interpretation or application, I could respect that answer,” Coons continued.

He then pointed to the amendment’s language, which says, “No person shall be elected to the office of the president more than twice,” noting that Trump has already won two presidential elections.

“I don’t understand how there’s any political debate here, sir. Could you help me understand your answer?”

Sullivan responded by saying he would look to the amendment’s text and the historical context surrounding its adoption rather than directly answer whether Trump could legally seek another term.

“Senator, it strikes me that the reason that we’re talking about this is because you’ve mentioned comments that the president has made about this in the press. And so what I can tell you is about how, whether it’s with the 22nd Amendment or any other, and I do appreciate the refresher on it, that’s why they write these things down and I keep it with me.”

“I would be looking to the text of the provision and the original public meaning of that text, at, you know, what it meant to the people and the states who ratified it at the time that they did it. My recollection is that that was in the wake of the Roosevelt, Franklin Delano Roosevelt.”

Coons kept pressing him, asking whether anyone could reasonably read the amendment as allowing a third presidential term. He also pointed to the events that led to the amendment’s adoption after Franklin D. Roosevelt won four presidential elections.

The exchange comes as Trump has repeatedly entertained running for another term, despite the constitutional restriction. He continues to falsely claim that someone stole the 2020 election from him and uses that claim to suggest he deserves another term as president.

At a rally in Iowa last month, Trump acknowledged that the law appeared to prevent him from running again before repeating his false claims about the 2020 election, according to The Guardian.

“I think I have the right to run again because they cheated,” Trump said, drawing applause from the crowd.

Trump has repeatedly floated the idea of a third term, at times joking about it and at other times suggesting he would like to pursue it. His allies, including House Speaker Mike Johnson, have dismissed the idea as trolling Democrats, while critics have expressed concern that Trump may be serious.

Sullivan is now seeking a federal judgeship after losing his Texas Supreme Court seat in the state’s recent Democratic sweep. Trump praised him as “an incredible jurist and lawyer” when announcing his nomination. Texas Sen. John Cornyn also defended Sullivan’s qualifications, saying the election outcome did not diminish his credentials, according to the Texas Tribune.

But the confirmation hearing exchange prompted sharp reactions online, with critics questioning how a judicial nominee could struggle with a constitutional amendment and then refuse to clearly state what it means.

“This is bad,” one observer noted.

Another commenter wrote: “The moment this man, a judge, couldn’t recall the 22nd Amendment (Section 1) to the U.S. Constitution they should’ve sounded the gavel, ended the confirmation hearing and every senator in that room should’ve gotten up and walked out. Incompetence on levels we’ve never seen.”

Others were equally critical of Sullivan’s response after Coons explained the amendment, with one person saying: “These are the morons that Trump is trying to nominate to lifetime appointments that don’t even know the law, but are afraid to address the real law. Absolutely frightening.”

Subscribe To The ABS Newsletter — Get our stories in your inbox.

Independent journalism still matters.

We hope this story was worth your time. For over 14 years, Atlanta Black Star has stayed Black-owned and independently run. We didn't get here by waiting on ad budgets that were never built to prioritize us. Our readers did that.

Corporate support for Black media has always been thin. Outlets like ours get roughly 1% of the $170 billion spent on U.S. advertising each year, and that margin is shrinking further as advertisers walk back the DEI-linked commitments they made in 2020. That's the backdrop. It's not why we're asking.

The wider picture isn't any steadier. Newspaper ad revenue has fallen more than 80% since 2005, and local newsrooms are closing at a rate of roughly two a week nationwide. When outlets go under, it's rarely the ones built to center a Black perspective from the ground up that get to stick around.

We know a request for support isn't why you came here. But without readers choosing to fund this work directly, the depth of reporting we can do at home and abroad shrinks along with everyone else's. If you're not in a position to give, that doesn't change how much we value you as a reader.

If you are able to, a recurring contribution does more for us than a single one-time gift, because it lets us plan the next investigation instead of just the next invoice. It takes about 30 seconds, no long form, no account. Thank you for continuing to support independent journalism and freedom of the press.

Latest from Atlanta Black Star

Back to top