New York Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand went toe to toe with the acting Navy secretary during a tense exchange over service members’ suicide attempts, at one point even sarcastically asking whether one sailor who went overboard was “trying to swim to Guam.”
The fiery clash happened Tuesday during acting Secretary Hung Cao’s confirmation hearing before the Senate Armed Services Committee.
Gillibrand grilled Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s top Navy nominee. She wanted to know more about the deplorable conditions aboard the USS Abraham Lincoln and eight sailors’ attempted suicides during the ship’s record deployment this year.

One of the sailors jumped overboard last March as the Lincoln’s deployment began to stretch out after Trump attacked Iran in late February.
Cao admitted to calling news reports about family members’ concerns for sailors aboard the Lincoln “dishonest.” He also admitted accusing the media of “trying to paint our warriors as victims.”
Cao said he spoke to sailors on the Lincoln at the time “and they felt the same way.”
“I disagree with your assessment,” the New York senator fired back.
Gillibrand brought up the oversight letter she sent to Cao in August and his response confirming eight sailors from the Lincoln tried to end their lives, including the service member who jumped overboard in March.
Gillibrand said in the letter Cao admitted that the Lincoln experienced piping failures, desalination issues and rationed hygiene supplies. She asked Cao whether President Donald Trump and Hegseth were wrong to dismiss concerns about conditions aboard the aircraft carrier.
“Well again Senator these were eight mitigations we were able to mitigate,” he began before Gillibrand shut him down.
“Please don’t call attempted suicides mitigations,” an animated Gillibrand yelled. “That is such an insult. It’s an insult to these men and women who are devoting their lives to the armed services. When you say it’s mitigation you’re compartmentalizing something that is clearly a mental health failure.”
Gillibrand told him that the fact that a sailor went overboard is “beyond a mitigation.”
Cao argued that the sailor was not trying to kill himself because he had a life jacket on when he jumped into the sea.
“He admitted that,” Cao claimed.
‘What was he trying to do? Swim to Guam?” an astounded Gillibrand demanded.
“He was trying to get out, he he jumped overboard with a life preserver on,” Cao stuttered.
Gillibrand cut him off. “Is there a logical explanation for jumping overboard to get out of service?”
“It will result in death,” she told him, answering her own question.
Cao denied that. “No it does not, senator.”
Gillibrand drilled down. “Did he jump overboard where he could swim to shore?”
Cao repeated that the sailor had a life preserver on, but the senator shot back, “I think you are minimizing what mental health strain is on these service members.”
The service members on the Lincoln spent nine months at sea before they were relieved in August.
Trump’s deadly and unapproved war on Iran led to fresh food shortages on the vessel in the war’s aftermath. In addition, sailors told family members about broken toilets and deteriorating conditions on the ship.
During an Oval Office press gaggle in mid-August, Trump again dismissed concerns about the state of the Lincoln, including mold, mental health issues among the crew, and the food situation.
And it looks like a repeat is unfolding aboard the USS George H.W. Bush. MS NOW reported that Navy leaders told service members’ families in a recent town hall that the aircraft carrier would not be home for the holidays
Cao, who was at that meeting, apologized for the extended deployment, saying Iran was “peppering” U.S. ships enforcing a naval blockade against the country. It’s the second time the ship’s deployment has been extended since March and Cao told families the ship could be at sea for a year.
Family members at the meeting called out Navy leadership. According to MS NOW, one person called the Iran war “unsanctioned.” Another accused the Navy of giving them “the runaround.”
And this family member accused Navy brass of putting service members at risk.
“Trust within the force and among our families is heavily strained right now between record-breaking stretches without relief, shifting timelines and the feeling that communication downplays the reality on the ground. Families are burning out under the immense strain.”
