Shatoya ‘Toya’ Malveaux, a Black real estate agent, spent two hours trying to cash a $23,379.69 cashier’s check with her name on it at a Texas bank that refused to cash it without providing a valid explanation.
It then took five minutes for the same bank to cash the check after Malveaux’s white colleague showed up to sign the check along with Malveaux.
Last month, Malveaux filed a federal lawsuit against Stellar Bank, now known as Prosperity Bank after a July merger, as well as bank manager Nef Prieto — the man who refused the transaction — accusing them of racial discrimination, wrongful refusal to pay a cashier’s check, and violations of Texas consumer-protection law.

“Defendants acted with intent to discriminate against Ms. Malveaux on the basis of her race,” states the federal lawsuit filed on Oct. 25 by attorney Courtney A. Vincent of Houston.
“But for her race, Defendants would have paid the Cashier’s Check when she presented it.”
The incident took place on Nov. 5, 2025, after Malveaux entered Stellar Bank in Katy, which is 30 miles west of Houston, and presented two forms of identification – something she had done multiple times on prior occasions at the same bank, according to the claim.
But this time, bank manager Prieto refused to cash the check payable to Malveaux and issued by Stellar Bank itself, even though she presented two forms of identification.
“A cashier’s check is a bank’s own promise to pay,” said attorney Vincent in a press release. “Ms. Malveaux brought that promise to the bank that made it, with her identification in hand.”
Malveaux’s lawsuit is at least the third filed by a Black person since 2024 after a bank refused to cash their check.
Malveaux, a licensed real estate agent for approximately eight years, had previously cashed commission checks at the same Katy branch despite never holding an account with Stellar Bank, according to the complaint.
It identifies a June 24, 2025 transaction that was completed “without incident” and says Prieto was not involved. Malveaux first met him on the day he allegedly refused to cash it.
The disputed funds originated with a $28,379.69 commission check Keller Williams issued to Malveaux in October 2025. On Oct. 30, Stellar Bank’s Dallas branch accepted that check, paid her $3,000 in cash, and issued a cashier’s check for the remaining $25,379.69.
Malveaux returned to the Dallas branch on Nov. 4, received another $2,000 in cash, and obtained a second cashier’s check for the $23,379.69 balance.
That second check, which she presented in Katy the following day, was payable to Malveaux and drawn by Stellar Bank on itself. It listed Stellar Bank as the remitter and bore two bank signatures.
The Dallas branch manager recommended that Malveaux cash it at the branch in Katy because that location handled high-volume cash transactions, the complaint says. The manager also gave her a business card so employees there could verify the check.
When Malveaux presented the check in Katy, a teller asked where she had obtained it. Malveaux explained that it came from the Dallas branch manager and provided the business card, according to her claim.
Prieto contacted the Dallas branch but refused payment afterward, the claim states.
He told Malveaux the bank was not obligated to cash the check and that she needed to cash it elsewhere.
“When she asked why, he told her that he did not need to give her a reason,” the claim states.
“The only other thing he said was that she was not a customer.”
Malveaux alleges Prieto pushed the check back across the counter toward her with two fingers. She stayed for approximately two hours, trying to obtain payment, and called her husband from inside the branch to describe what was happening.
One police officer was already stationed at the entrance, and a second arrived while she waited, according to the lawsuit. The second officer stood at the door watching her but did not approach or speak to her. Malveaux says his presence made her feel intimidated and afraid.
She eventually left without her money.
After leaving, Malveaux contacted Barker, her team leader at Keller Williams Signature, and went to their brokerage office, crying when she got to the office.
Both women later returned to the branch together, with Malveaux again presenting identification, but Barker presenting neither identification nor a business card, the claim states.
Before releasing the money, the bank required both women to sign a “Cash Withdrawal Waiver of Liability,” which described an account holder withdrawing money “from my account(s) in cash,” the complaint states.
A teller directed Barker to sign first as the “Account Holder,” then asked Malveaux to sign the same lines, even though the check was payable to Malveaux and Barker had no written authority to act on it.
The branch paid the entire $23,379.69 within approximately five minutes after Barker arrived.
Malveaux returned to the branch on Feb. 4, 2026, and recorded conversations with Prieto, asking what a non-customer would need to cash a Stellar Bank cashier’s check exceeding $20,000.
He allegedly answered, “Just your ID,” possibly a second form of identification.
“You don’t need an account to cash a check that’s drawn off of us,” the complaint quotes him as saying, contradicting the claims he made three months earlier.
The lawsuit invokes Section 1981, a federal civil rights law that prohibits racial discrimination in contractual transactions.
“Section 1981 guarantees every person the same right to make and enforce contracts that white citizens enjoy, and this case asks the court to enforce that guarantee.”
“The Cashier’s Check, its payee, its amount, and the identification Ms. Malveaux had presented were the same before and after Ms. Barker arrived,” the claim states.
Although she ultimately received the full payment that day, Malveaux says the encounter left her with nightmares, anxiety, a racing heart, panic, and crying spells. She alleges that she becomes anxious when entering banks and that the incident impaired her ability to work.