Black New Mexico Homeowner Files Lawsuit After Police Mistook Her for a Burglar

An Abiquiu, New Mexico homeowner has filed a federal lawsuit against the Rio Arriba Sheriff’s Department after a wrongful arrest back in 2014.

After moving from New York state, Charlene Carroll moved to the rural community to get some peace and quiet. However, that peace came to screeching halt on Aug. 25, 2014 during an encounter with deputies. In an exclusive with KOB 4 News, Carroll tells reporters that she was adjusting quite well to her new home before the arrest.

“My neighbors have accepted me,” Carroll says. “I’ve pretty much been accepted in the jobs that I have here. But this one incident, I couldn’t believe it was happening.”

According to KOB 4 News, one of her neighbors called in a suspected burglary around 10:45 pm on the 25th. She recalls working on the computer when she saw people outside her home. “He walked around the house peeping in the windows so he could see that nothing was amiss,” she explains.

The two men were deputies Randy Sanches and Brandon Archuleta, per court documents. They told Carroll that they were investigating the 911 call and demanded entry into her home. But the homeowner requested a search warrant before she granted them access to her home.

“I said [to them], ‘So I’m arrested on my own front porch now?’” Carroll recalls saying. “I was taken out of [the] handcuffs. Officer Archuleta escorted me all of the way to the bedroom on the other side of the house where I pointed to a picture of myself on the wall.”

She also showed the officers on scene her driver’s license but officers did not believe her. Officers did not let her go until the neighbor that made the 911 call arrived and told them she was not the suspected burglar.

“It doesn’t matter how educated I am,” Carroll reflects. “It doesn’t matter how much money I have [or] what kind of person I am. I will always be defined by the color of my skin and that’s just the way it is.”

However, the Rio Arriba Sheriff’s Office refutes her claims put forth by the lawsuit. In a response, the department states that Carroll did not identify herself as the homeowner. They also denied that deputies demanded to be let in the home.

Subscribe To The ABS Newsletter — Get our stories in your inbox.

Independent journalism still matters.

We hope this story was worth your time. For over 14 years, Atlanta Black Star has stayed Black-owned and independently run. We didn't get here by waiting on ad budgets that were never built to prioritize us. Our readers did that.

Corporate support for Black media has always been thin. Outlets like ours get roughly 1% of the $170 billion spent on U.S. advertising each year, and that margin is shrinking further as advertisers walk back the DEI-linked commitments they made in 2020. That's the backdrop. It's not why we're asking.

The wider picture isn't any steadier. Newspaper ad revenue has fallen more than 80% since 2005, and local newsrooms are closing at a rate of roughly two a week nationwide. When outlets go under, it's rarely the ones built to center a Black perspective from the ground up that get to stick around.

We know a request for support isn't why you came here. But without readers choosing to fund this work directly, the depth of reporting we can do at home and abroad shrinks along with everyone else's. If you're not in a position to give, that doesn't change how much we value you as a reader.

If you are able to, a recurring contribution does more for us than a single one-time gift, because it lets us plan the next investigation instead of just the next invoice. It takes about 30 seconds, no long form, no account. Thank you for continuing to support independent journalism and freedom of the press.

Latest from Atlanta Black Star

Back to top